So How Fast Is NAS Under Tomato? You May Be Surprised!

15 Feb

Hav­ing suc­cess­fully setup a low cost NAS, I wanted to find out how fast my NAS was. More so, since the folks at DD-WRT and Tomato worked pretty hard to get USB work­ing on the Asus 520gu. It all boiled down to Samba ver­sus Win­dows. The results were an eye opener!

Objec­tive:

To deter­mine net­work access speed on an exter­nal USB drive attached to Asus WL-520gu run­ning Tomato with Samba ver­sus access speed on the same net­work, when access­ing a Win­dows share on a PC run­ning XP.

Setup:

Asus WL-520gu flashed with Tomato V1.23

San­disk Cruzer 1GB USB flash drive, FAT32

A win­dows share on a PC run­ning XP, NTFS

Yeah ok, FAT32 with NTFS!  I don’t have a high tech lab here, I make do with what I have! :)

Results

Flash drive attached to router (Test I)

Router Share

Win­dows share on a PC (Test I)

Windows Share

Flash drive attached to router (Test II)

Router Share (Test II)

Win­dows share on a PC (Test II)

Windows Share (Test II)

Con­clu­sion

These are actu­ally very sur­pris­ing results!  The flash drive attached to the router actu­ally per­forms bet­ter than a native Win­dows share!

Related Posts with Thumbnails

No comments yet

Leave a Reply